General Common Law

Contractual Disputes: Enforcement and Defences

An introduction to enforcing contracts in Irish law, and the common defences available when a breach is alleged.

Contracts are the foundation of commercial relationships. When one party alleges that another has breached a contract, litigation may follow. Understanding the principles of contract enforcement—and the defences available—is essential for businesses and individuals alike.

Enforcing a Contract

To succeed in a breach of contract claim, the plaintiff must establish: 1. That a valid, enforceable contract existed 2. That the defendant breached a term of that contract 3. That the plaintiff suffered loss as a result

The remedy sought is typically damages (financial compensation), though in some cases specific performance (an order requiring the defendant to perform their obligations) may be available.

Common Defences

Defendants in breach of contract cases may raise a number of defences: • No contract was formed (e.g., lack of agreement, consideration, or intention to create legal relations) • The contract is void or unenforceable (e.g., due to misrepresentation, duress, or illegality) • The alleged breach did not occur, or was not material • The plaintiff failed to mitigate their losses • The contract contains an exclusion or limitation clause that applies

Contractual disputes can be complex and fact-intensive. Early legal advice is crucial to assess your position and explore settlement before matters escalate.

Need Legal Advice?

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, please get in touch.